| Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | For | Agst |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 38 | 17 | 10 | 11 | 59 | 41 |
| Date | Competition | Opponents | Venue | Score | Goalscorers | Att | Rep | Vid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29/11/1958 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 4-1 | Edgar(3),Patrick | 6121 |  | |
| 18/04/1959 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-3 | Terry | 2913 |  | |
| 30/01/1960 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-3 | Albury | 2459 |  | |
| 23/04/1960 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 3-1 | Brown,Terry,Smith(p) | 5274 |  | |
| 29/10/1960 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 5-1 | Pulley(2),Bacon,Shepherd,Terry | 3816 |  | |
| 18/03/1961 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-1 | 2152 |  | ||
| 18/11/1961 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 4-0 | Pulley,Farrall(2),Livesey | 6502 |  | |
| 07/04/1962 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 3-1 | Pulley(2),Farrall | 2254 |  | |
| 30/03/1963 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 5-1 | Farrall,Arnott,Towers,Gibbs,Francis | 5330 |  | |
| 01/04/1963 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-1 | Ballagher | 2470 |  | |
| 14/09/1963 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-0 | 2608 |  | ||
| 18/01/1964 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-0 | Newman(2) | 7536 |  | |
| 01/02/1969 | Div 3 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-2 | T.Simpson,Woodley | 4785 |  | |
| 10/03/1969 | Div 3 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-1 | Riddick | 2401 |  | |
| 18/09/1971 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 1-0 | Yeo | 5477 |  | |
| 01/01/1972 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-3 | Galvin | 2932 |  | |
| 23/10/1972 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-2 | 3442 |  | ||
| 13/01/1973 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-0 | Galvin,Richardson | 3071 |  | |
| 22/09/1973 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-2 | Jacks | 1383 |  | |
| 10/02/1974 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 3-0 | OG,Wilks,Yeo | 8754 |  | |
| 09/09/1989 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 2-1 | Palmer,Heritage | 1600 |  |  |
| 27/01/1990 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 0-0 | 3676 |  | ||
| 08/09/1990 | Div 4 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 3-0 | Lovell(2),Heritage | 3155 |  | |
| 30/04/1991 | Div 4 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-1 | 3782 |  | | |
| 13/08/1994 | Div 3 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 0-0 | 2959 |  | | |
| 17/09/1994 | Div 3 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-2 | 1756 |  | | |
| 28/10/1995 | Div 3 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-1 | Bailey(p) | 2355 |  | |
| 06/04/1996 | Div 3 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-0 | T.Butler,Bailey | 6263 |  | |
| 01/11/2005 | Div 1 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-3 | Collin | 4522 | | |
| 19/11/2005 | Div 1 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 1-0 | Shields | 6092 | | |
| 24/11/2007 | Div 1 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-1 | Oli(2) | 5488 | | |
| 08/03/2008 | Div 1 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-4 | 4055 | | ||
| 22/08/2009 | Div 1 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 0-1 | 4696 | | ||
| 26/01/2010 | Div 1 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 1-1 | Jackson | 2465 |  | |
| 10/11/2018 | FAC1 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 0-0 | 2224 | | | |
| 21/11/2018 | FAC1R | Hartlepool Utd | A | 4-3 (aet) | Ehmer,Eaves(p),O'Neill,List | 1873 | | |
| 24/09/2022 | Div 2 | Hartlepool Utd | A | 0-0 | 4898 | | | |
| 14/01/2023 | Div 2 | HARTLEPOOL UTD | H | 2-0 | Nichols,Jefferies | 6003 | | |