| PlayerName | Opponents | First Season | Last Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| McDonald | MILLWALL ATHLETIC | 1897-98 | 1897-98 |
| McDonald | PORTSMOUTH | 1904-05 | 1908-09 |
| McDonald | WELLINGBOROUGH | 1904-05 | 1904-05 |
| McDonald | QUEENS PARK RANGERS | 1908-09 | 1908-09 |
| McDonald | LLOYDS PAPER MILLS | 1944-45 | 1944-45 |