| PlayerName | Opponents | First Season | Last Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caldwell | HIGHLAND LIGHT INFANTRY | 1893-94 | 1893-94 |
| Caldwell | WOOLWICH ARSENAL | 1897-98 | 1897-98 |
| Caldwell | BRIGHTON UTD | 1898-99 | 1898-99 |
| Caldwell | SOUTHEND UTD | 1908-09 | 1908-09 |
| Caldwell | READING | 1909-10 | 1909-10 |
| Caldwell | BATH CITY | 1946-47 | 1947-48 |